This is a feature
from the No-Anorexia 2007 advertisement
campaign by the Italian fashion designer Nolita. These shocking posters depict the
emaciated, gaunt, 4st 8lb body of actress and model, Isabelle Caro. The
campaign was intended to break the silence which surrounds anorexia, and to raise
awareness of the dangers of eating disorders. The use of a naked body is
hard-hitting and poignant in raising awareness of an issue that is so often
imposed by stereotypes of what it means to be "beautiful". The fact that this advertisement has been generated by a
fashion brand directly challenges that the stick-thin "beauty" stereotype
is what designers want. Thus, the creators of the advert establish themselves
as a credible source for the delivery of the persuasive message that
"beautiful" does not mean what is seen in the advert.
A primary persuasive
tactic this advert utilizes is that of a vivid appeal. All three aspects of a
vivid appeal (Pratkanis, 2007) have been met in this advert: it is emotionally
engaging, image provoking, and immediate. More specifically, the type of vivid
appeal in the advert is that of a fear appeal. The arousal of fear creates an
aversive state which we want to avoid: a desire to escape danger. This advert
aims to raise awareness of avoiding anorexic behaviour by creating a fear state
of what may happen to you if you don't.
This fear appeal uses
a tactic of disgust to scare the targets of the advertisement. Morales, Wu, and
Fitzsimons (2012) demonstrate that by adding disgust to a fear appeal, the
persuasive power and thus behavioural compliance is significantly enhanced
beyond that of appeals that elicit only fear. It is hypothesized that disgust
specifically exploits our natural avoidance tendency. In the research by
Morales et al. (2012), participants were shown advertisement posters for the
reduction of meth-amphetamine use that utilized fear only, fear and disgust, or
neutral emotion tactics. The disgusting image showed a teenager with open sores
on his face, the scary image was a coffin, and the neutral image was two teenagers
sitting side by side. Participants indicated greater levels of persuasion and
compliance (indicated lower likelihoods via questionnaire of their future drug
use over the next 2 months) in response to a disgust-inducing fear appeal
relative to both a non-disgusting fear appeal and a control appeal.
Morales, A.
C., Wu, E. C., & Fitzsimons, G. J. (2012). How disgust enhances the
effectiveness of fear appeals. Journal of
Marketing Research, 49, 383-393.
Pratkanis, A. R. (2007). The
science of social influence: Advances and future progress. New York: Psychology
Press.
Well done, and quite a bit scary.
ReplyDelete