I think everyone will remember seeing this THINK road safety
advert as a child. If it wasn’t the catchy song, then the little hedgehogs
would be sure to stick in your mind. Commissioned by the government to promote
road safety in children, this adverts underlying aim was to limit the number of
children’s injuries and deaths caused by road accidents. Rather than focusing
on statistical evidence, or on the fearful consequences of not looking when
crossing the road, this advert cleverly uses cartoon hedgehogs to express the
message to children to always stop, and think, before going to cross the road.
This advert worked so well because of the Storytelling technique. This is when you
use narrative to provide structure to facts, and guide decision making (Pratkanis, 2007). The
emotions and imagery a story triggers may instil beliefs in the reader that are
consistent with the story.
Supporting this, research by Green and Brock (2000) found
that the more subjects were transported into a story about a murder at shopping
mall, the more likely the subjects were to believe that shopping malls were
unsafe. In this study, 97 undergraduates read "Murder at the Mall," a
story about a student, whose little sister is stabbed to death by a psychiatric
patient in a mall. The story was framed as being either fiction or nonfiction to
subjects.
Subjects completed a series of questionnaires before and
after reading the story, regarding violence, psychiatric patients, a
just-world, and whether crime doesn’t pay. Subjects answered whether "Psychiatric
patients who live in an institution should be allowed to go out in the
community during the day" and whether they should have "passes to leave
their institution…free of supervision." Violence questions asked subjects
to rate how frequent they thought stabbing deaths occurred in Ohio malls, and
in the United States. The just-world index investigated whether subjects’
perception of whether the world was just, was changed after reading the story. Subjects
then completed a 15-item transportation questionnaire. This asked subjects the extent
to which they agreed with statements like, “the events in the narrative have changed
my life.”
Transportation into the story
|
||
Question
|
High
|
Low
|
Violence
|
11.35
|
10.26
|
Psychiatric patients
|
95.93
|
87.45
|
Just world
|
55.89
|
50.74
|
Crime doesn’t pay
|
47.65
|
46.21
|
Table 1: Mean ratings for each question from
subjects who reported being highly transported into the story, compared to
subjects who reported low transportation into the story.
We can clearly see from Table 1 that those who reported
higher transportation into the story, reported beliefs that were more
consistent with the story. This is shown in the higher mean ratings for each
question. For instance, subjects who
were highly transported into the story reported that more violence existed in
the world, that psychiatric patient freedoms should be restricted, and reported
just-world beliefs that were more consistent with the story, than lower
transported subjects. The amount of transportation into the story did not
differ depending on whether the subject was told the story was fact or fiction.
Overall, this shows that stories can change people’s beliefs and attitudes.
In the case of
the THINK road safety advert, the hedgehogs cleverly tell a story to the
children in the form of a rhyming song. This narrative works so well because
children become swept up by the song, and become transported into the story. The
advert ensures that children are reminded that they are responsible: “You know
your own street, and everyone you meet.” However, the narrative of the song informs
children that “though you know the road well, still you never can tell, you’ve
got to be wise,” when crossing even familiar roads. This instils the message
that roads can be dangerous (especially as the advert shows giraffe drivers speeding
down the road out of nowhere). The story increases the likelihood that children
will remember the song when they are about to cross the road, and will STOP.
THINK. And GO!
Green, M. C.
& Brock, T. C. (2000). The Role of Transportation in the Persuasiveness of
Public Narratives. Journal of Personality
and Social Psychology, 79(5), 701-721.
Pratkanis, A. R. (2007). The
science of social influence: Advances and future progress. Hove: Psychology
Press.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.